Review: Fakin’ It XL – A Hilarious Party Game That Puts Your Bluffing Skills to the Test

Fakin' It XL Review

Developed and published by Jackbox Games, Fakin’ It XL is a standalone version of the Fakin’ It game mode originally introduced in The Jackbox Party Pack 3. The standalone release lives up to the XL name by adding content, new modes, and several quality-of-life improvements, letting players enjoy this party game without buying an entire Jackbox Party Pack. This is our review of the PC Steam version of Fakin’ It XL, where we attempt to bluff our way to victory and convince everyone that our suspicious answers are completely legitimate.

If you have been playing Jackbox Games titles for some time, you will probably remember Fakin’ It as one of the mini-games included in The Jackbox Party Pack 3. Its standalone release is an interesting move, particularly considering how much replayability the original game mode offered. Rather than simply bringing the same experience to a separate release, Jackbox Games has expanded it with additional content and improvements to make it a more complete package. Like most Jackbox Games releases, Fakin’ It XL is a multiplayer-only experience that uses a second screen, such as a mobile phone, tablet, or another monitor connected to your PC.

Fakin' It XL Review

The central objective in Fakin’ It XL remains simple: identify the faker among the players before they manage to convince everyone that they belong. The game features different mini-games built around questions, instructions, and small challenges. In most rounds, everyone except the faker receives the same prompt. These can range from answering hypothetical questions, such as which actor would make a better James Bond, to pointing at another player who would be the best candidate for becoming the group’s alpha.

While everyone else receives a proper question or instruction, the faker gets a vague prompt that provides just enough information to participate without revealing what everyone else is doing. This forces the designated player to improvise, observe the other participants, and come up with believable answers without knowing the actual question. It is a simple concept, but it creates plenty of hilarious situations, especially when the faker has absolutely no idea what everyone else is talking about.

Fakin' It XL Review

Different game modes introduce different tasks for players to complete. These can range from giving a thumbs-up or thumbs-down in response to a question and pointing at a particular player to holding up a specific number of fingers or responding with a particular emoji. What I particularly liked is how each round introduces a different activity, keeping the experience fresh and preventing consecutive rounds from feeling too similar. The variety also makes it harder for players to predict what comes next, which adds to the overall fun. During the final round, even the Faker is not told that they are the odd one out, making it considerably more challenging to identify them. This small twist keeps the closing moments tense and entertaining.

Once everyone has submitted their answers, the game opens a short discussion window where players can question each other and try to identify the faker. Those who received the actual prompt can explain their choices, while the faker must rely on convincing lies and quick thinking to avoid suspicion. Players then vote for who they believe is the faker. If the group identifies the correct person, the round ends, but failing to catch them gives everyone another opportunity to figure things out. The faker also changes between rounds, while a randomly selected player gets to choose the next mini-game.

Fakin' It XL Review

What makes this gameplay loop enjoyable is how much it depends on the people playing rather than the actual questions. Someone who is naturally good at bluffing can easily turn a seemingly obvious situation into a hilarious debate, while players who are not particularly convincing can expose themselves within seconds. Even when everyone knows how the game works, the changing roles and different personalities involved keep the experience entertaining.

One of the best things about Fakin’ It XL is that only one person in a group needs to own the game. Other players can join the same session without purchasing their own copies, making it an accessible party game for groups that want to play together. Similar to other Jackbox Games releases, players join through Jackbox.TV using a room code displayed on the main screen. They can use a mobile browser, tablet, or another compatible device to enter their answers and interact with the game.

Fakin' It XL Review

I found playing with a dual-monitor setup particularly convenient, as it allowed me to keep the main game running on one display while using the other for player inputs. However, using a mobile phone or tablet works just as well, provided the device remains charged and close enough to the main display. The main screen acts as the host, displaying the questions, answers, and other gameplay information, while individual players use their secondary screens to participate.

Unfortunately, the experience has some limitations when playing remotely through Steam Remote Play. Players who join remotely cannot independently see everything happening on the main game screen. They can access their prompts and submit answers, but important information displayed on the host’s screen, including questions, submitted answers, and round results, may not be visible to them. They may also miss out on knowing whether the faker was caught or which player won unless the host shares their screen through another application or streams the gameplay over a call.

Fakin' It XL Review

While Remote Play is a welcome addition, this limitation makes it less convenient than playing together locally. It is particularly disappointing for a game that is designed around group discussions and reactions, as remote participants should ideally have access to the same information as everyone else. A more integrated screen-sharing solution would have made the experience considerably better.

Like most party games, Fakin’ It XL does not demand particularly powerful hardware, and getting everyone into a session is relatively straightforward. However, there are a few things worth considering before purchasing it. There is no traditional matchmaking system, meaning players can only join sessions using a room code. You will need friends, family members, or an existing group of players to enjoy the game, as there are no AI-controlled participants available to fill empty slots.

Fakin' It XL Review

This is understandable considering the nature of the experience. The entire concept revolves around human reactions, suspicious behaviour, and convincing lies, something that would be difficult to replicate with AI players. Nevertheless, it does limit the game’s accessibility for solo players who might want to try it without organizing a group beforehand.

There is also the matter of repeated questions and prompts. Fakin’ It XL does not feature an endlessly expanding collection of questions, and players will eventually start encountering familiar content after spending several hours with it. I noticed some repeated questions during my review, but this did not significantly affect my enjoyment. The actual entertainment comes from the people involved, the different roles assigned in each round, and the increasingly ridiculous explanations players come up with to defend themselves.

Fakin' It XL Review

Even when a familiar question appears, the outcome can be completely different depending on who is playing and who gets assigned the role of the faker. This gives Fakin’ It XL considerably more replayability than its relatively straightforward collection of questions might initially suggest.

Ultimately, Fakin’ It XL succeeds at delivering an accessible multiplayer party game that is easy to understand and fun to play with the right group of people. Its reliance on a second screen and lack of matchmaking are understandable design decisions, although the Remote Play limitations could certainly be improved. The repeated questions also become noticeable over time, but they do not completely undermine the experience. For players who enjoyed the original Fakin’ It mode, this standalone release offers a convenient way to revisit the concept without purchasing an entire party game collection.

Related Reviews:

Final Verdict:

Fakin’ It XL takes an already enjoyable party game and makes it more accessible through a standalone release, additional content, and quality-of-life improvements. Its simple gameplay loop creates plenty of hilarious moments, especially when players have to improvise their way out of suspicious situations. However, the lack of matchmaking, reliance on a second screen, Remote Play limitations, and eventually repetitive questions prevent it from being a perfect party game. Nevertheless, if you have a group of friends or family members to play with, Fakin’ It XL offers an entertaining multiplayer experience that can keep everyone laughing for hours.

Final Score: 8.5/10

Disclaimer: A PC Steam review code for Fakin’ It XL was sent by Tinsley PR on behalf of Jackbox Games for this review. For a detailed breakdown of our scoring and review process, please refer to our Review Policy.

You May Also Like

About the Author: Umair Khalid

Founder of GamesHedge, Umair enjoys a wide variety of video games ranging from RPGs to racing games. Currently playing Gears of War: Reloaded and Enshrouded.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.